CO129-120 - Sir MacDonnell - 1867 [1-2] — Page 232

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

230

be made to him I consider it should

only be as a gratuity for his extra personal trouble, and not for demurrage, though

As

his claim for actual additional expenditure

has already been conceded, and

These statements are

manifestly

of

unquestionably erroneous

of a native equivalent to direct perversion of the truth, I think his further claims

must be

slight.

One thing however is certain, viz:

that the sick seaman

probably

would have died, if detained here, has reached England alive, and I though the local Departmental arrangements

formerly lamentably defective, they

are now

longer. I therefore respectfully suggest that the Board of Trade need

have no apprehensions as to the future consequences of maintaining the principle that the life of the sailor is to be preferred

to the interest and convenience

of Ship owners,

especially as such cases are not unfrequently occurring, as we may learn from the Colonial Surgeon.

12.

I may add that my

attention has

been frequently attracted since my arrival here to the hardships inflicted

on men, so careless and thoughtless, as ordinary seamen generally are, by the selfishness of Masters of Vessels. The latter make no scruple often of getting rid of a great

proportion of their men when they arrive home, can do so with impunity, and

substitute cheaper labor during their stay

Edit History

2026-05-19 16:13:05 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
230 be made to him I consider it should only be as a gratuity for his extra personal trouble, and not for demurrage, though As his claim for actual additional expenditure has already been conceded, and These statements are manifestly of unquestionably erroneous of a native equivalent to direct perversion of the truth, I think his further claims must be slight. One thing however is certain, viz: that the sick seaman probably would have died, if detained here, has reached England alive, and I though the local Departmental arrangements formerly lamentably defective, they are now longer. I therefore respectfully suggest that the Board of Trade need have no apprehensions as to the future consequences of maintaining the principle that the life of the sailor is to be preferred to the interest and convenience of Ship owners, especially as such cases are not unfrequently occurring, as we may learn from the Colonial Surgeon. 12. I may add that my attention has been frequently attracted since my arrival here to the hardships inflicted on men, so careless and thoughtless, as ordinary seamen generally are, by the selfishness of Masters of Vessels. The latter make no scruple often of getting rid of a great proportion of their men when they arrive home, can do so with impunity, and substitute cheaper labor during their stay
Baseline (Original)
230 be made to him I consider it should only be as a gratuity for his cotra personal trible, and not for demurrage, though As his clain for actual additional expenditure bon has already bem conceded, and This statements are AJ marzy of unquestionably erongguations of a native equivalent to direct perversion of the truth, I think his further clarins must be 11. slight. One thing havever is certain, viz: that the sick seaman prebobility Avert she, in all human would have died, of detained. here, has reached England alive, and I though the local Departmental arrangements formerly lamentably defective, they lenger. I therefore respectfully suggest that the Board of Trade need are 20 mo have no apprehensions as to the future I consequences of maintaining the principele that the life of the sailor is to be preferred. to the interest and convenience cas m in ten Arv of Ship covers, frequent, especially as such quelably not trounty liventy learn from the Colonial Sungrow. year, 12. I may add that my a J > attention has ban frequently attracted since my here to the hardships inflicted arrival cop of men, so careless and thoughtlifs, as ordinary Quamen genually are, by the selfishnes of Masters of Vessels. The latter mate scruple often of golling rid of a great many Mo d proportion of their rohen they on. arriving hove, can de se wich infinity, and substitute cheaper labor during ethen
2026-05-19 16:13:05 · Baseline
View content

230

be made to him I consider it should

only be as a gratuity for his cotra personal trible, and not for demurrage, though

As

his clain for actual additional expenditure

bon

has already bem conceded, and

This statements are

AJ

marzy

of

unquestionably erongguations

of a native equivalent to direct perversion of the truth, I think his further clarins

must be

11.

slight.

One thing havever is certain, viz:

that the sick seaman

prebobility

Avert

she, in all human

would have died, of detained.

here, has reached England alive, and I though the local Departmental arrangements

formerly lamentably defective, they

lenger. I therefore respectfully suggest that the Board of Trade need

are 20 mo

have no apprehensions as to the future I consequences of maintaining the principele that the life of the sailor is to be preferred.

to the interest and convenience

cas m

in ten

Arv

of Ship covers,

frequent,

especially as such quelably not trounty liventy learn from the Colonial Sungrow.

year,

12.

I may add that my

a

J

>

attention has

ban frequently attracted since my here to the hardships inflicted

arrival

cop

of men, so careless and thoughtlifs, as ordinary

Quamen

genually are, by the selfishnes of Masters of Vessels. The latter mate scruple often of golling rid of a great

many

Mo d

proportion of their rohen they

on.

arriving hove, can de se wich infinity, and

substitute cheaper labor during ethen

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.